What does Fred Liu think about Carvana and Sea Limited? – Fred Liu
- Fred Liu and Hayden did 300+ meetings or calls in 2019, he says.
- Sea Limited was about a 4.5 billion dollar company when Hayden bought it, and about 40 billion dollars in 2020.
- Shopee reported about 140% year-over-year GMV growth in April 2020, as he recalls.
- E-commerce penetration in Southeast Asia was about 3% in 2020, he estimates.
- Hayden’s model had Carvana at about 15 billion dollars in sales within about four years (2020).
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from YouTube. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationSea Limited (SE) · Carvana (CVNA) · JD.com (JD)
Lazada (Alibaba, BABA) · CarMax (KMX)
Walmart (WMT) · SL Green Realty (SLG) · Amazon (AMZN) · Tencent (0700.HK) · ByteDance (private)
How did Fred Liu become an investor?
TL;DR: He got 15 shares of Walmart at 11, worked at JP Morgan and New Street Research and then launched Hayden Capital (2020).
[00:01:57] 
[00:02:23] 
I started listening to CNBC, watching Jim Cramer, trying to get an earnings box. Needless to say, over the course of summer, I lost everything that I had. It was a couple of thousand bucks that I had saved up until that painful for 12, 13 years old. And I started going to penny stocks taught me around about level 2, quote, bid, ask spreads, all of that. So that was a good lesson. After that experience, I went to the library and said: “There must be a better way to pursue investing.” And so the first book that kind of always stares at you is Warren Buffett. Right? He’s kind of the most famous investor.
And so I picked up the book “The Warren Buffett Way”. It was one of the first books. And then I read a lot about value investing throughout that period of school in high school. And by the time I got to high school, I knew I wanted to be an investor. I had done banking internships. I took classes at Columbia University by that point, and I fell in love with the kind of discipline. My dad wanted me to be an engineer. He sent me to like summer camp to try to force me to be an engineer. I knew I didn’t want to do it. He’s a mechanical engineer himself.
[00:04:26] 
[00:04:27] 
When I first started in college, definitely like everyone. I kind of gravitated towards the net-nets “The detailing type of names” like I was saying. I think most investors that I know kind of start off in that space, either because it’s simpler to understand or it’s like a quantitative exercise rather than qualitative. I think as an investor, you don’t appreciate the qualitative aspects of the business until you get more sophisticated as you progress in your career. So, like my first stock was during that time was SL Green Realty Corp during the financial crisis. You can still find things like that. I was evaluating like “What is the net asset value of all of the office space that they own within Manhattan” and trying to run some calculations based on that and being able to buy at like half their bulk of what I calculate as their book.
And then I have made my way to JP Morgan. They had a much more quality kind of focus within small-cap space, looking for names under two billion dollars with five analysts. And so that helped hone my philosophy a lot. The problem with working at a larger asset management firm and a more institutional firm is that there is a big push towards not only force diversification, but also, for instance, we were closed at the time. JP Morgan would force us to open new products and whatnot. And I could just feel our time getting stretched, if we were evaluating a new name. I talked to other friends at other firms. So it’s not just firms like JP Morgan, but other firms as well. You only have so much time to go deep into each individual name. I felt like that wasn’t the right way to proceed to investing.
And so it was around that time that I started thinking about: What does a great investment firm look like from a client standpoint? How do you structure the firm so that everything is aligned in the client’s best interests? And then also how can the frustration. I also had to start realizing at that time, just talking to a lot of people in industries, I realized a lot of people sit behind their computer screens and think that they can have an edge on the market. By doing that, they feel more comfortable because there’s a lot more information on the Internet nowadays. But I think the underappreciated part is understanding the incremental unit economics behind selling these businesses. And you’re never going to find that on the Internet, right? By the time it’s in a 10K or a public filing, it’s already relatively well known.
So, I think a lot of the edge in the market today is just doing the good old fashioned channel checks, talking to as many people as possible. So I wanted to build an eventually build a firm like that after JP I went to a firm called The New Street, a boutique research shop. They do really good work around the new economic analysis that I was talking about.
And they also do really good workaround building their networks and trying to get information from people just through industry sources or through relationships that they already have. And so after New Street, I decided to launch Hayden. We’ve kind of been pursuing that strategy ever since. It’s gotten honed over the last couple of years. But the basic core principles are the same.
How does Fred Liu research and what is his edge?
TL;DR: Hayden did 300 plus meetings or calls last year. He sees Southeast Asia entering the golden zone of 2,000 to 4,000 US dollars GDP per capita (2020).
How many meetings does he take?
[00:08:52] 
[00:08:58] 
How does he prepare?
[00:09:29] 
[00:09:44] 
I think there’s something to learn from everyone. And even if, let’s say both of you have disagreeing views on a certain stock, there’s always that those are the best conversations right. So I try to meet everyone that I can to get a holistic view of a certain topic that I’m trying to have a better grasp upon. And so meetings, I mean, yeah, the meetings take a little bit of prep time, maybe like 30 minutes. Forty-five minutes beforehand, just writing down a couple of questions. But other than that, the conversations flow pretty naturally.
What is the best edge?
[00:10:43] 
[00:11:00] 
And if you were sitting in an emerging market and have firsthand experience with it, I think that’s a real edge against a lot of the investors, the more professional investors. And so I try to do the same thing, even though, for instance, we have some investments in Southeast Asia, I can’t use the product, but talking to as many customers as possible I think helps me get closer to that first-hand experience.
Which biases are outdated?
[00:11:59] 
[00:12:21] 
Good Investing Plus
Meet the experienced investors
Plus is our application-based community of 200+ investors. Around half run or support a fund, or allocate capital.
- Online: idea exchanges and events every two weeks
- In person: gatherings in the US and Europe
- Omaha: our 150+ member conference in AGM week
Right. And they benefited from it. If you look at, for instance, average incomes in China in the early 2000s, up until 2010, 2012, it was growing at high teens. Imagine your personal salary growing 20 percent every year. Right. That that instills a different type of mindset, like you, can’t lose type mindset. But as China has slowed, I think and just anecdotally, I’ve noticed this as well, a lot of management teams are becoming more rational. A lot of management teams have experience with Western companies or have worked inside of Western companies. They have a much better sophistication around capital allocation, return on invested capital, what have you.
And so these companies are changing. It’s just a natural dynamic that you see when a country starts maturing and the pie doesn’t grow so rapidly that you can just toss money against the wall and it’s going to bring you back a bucks or a four for each dollar that you throw. And so you’re starting to see that in China today. And I think Asia changes so rapidly that if you have a bias from even five years ago, 10 years ago, that bias is probably outdated. So I think that that’s probably something that not a lot of people quite appreciate just yet. And I would suggest anyone just go visit Asia if you haven’t already and then start talking to people. I think I think you’ll be pretty impressed with the business environment there.
Why Southeast Asia now?
[00:14:33] 
[00:14:37] 
You’re starting to see a lot more startups come up as well. There aren’t quite that many listed companies. Sea is a great example, but they’re listed in New York in terms of local companies. The quality isn’t quite there yet. But if you look at the earlier stages, the series A, B, C. There’s quite a few like mature tech firms in the region. I think over the next five years you’re going to see these firms succeed and they’re going to start being listed. And I think part of the opportunity is just understanding the market, getting ahead of it so that in five years when these companies start being listed, you have its advantage there.
How does Shopee compete with Lazada and what is Sea Limited?
TL;DR: Shopee customers order about four or five times a month. E-commerce penetration in the region is about 3%, he says (2020).
How does Shopee win?
[00:16:04] 
[00:16:22] 
If you look at surveys in the region, a lot of people are willing to wait in terms of the delivery time for a piece of apparel versus maybe a brand new cell phone, a cell phone you may want tomorrow because you have some urgent need for it. And so that’s where they started off and they started off in the CDC marketplace focusing on kind of long-tail inventory. Lazada has basically started moving in the direction of Shopee as well. And Shopee likewise has started selling electronics, home goods, how normal household appliances, and whatnot.
So I think you’re starting to see them converge with it. But the difference is really in the culture of shopping, either really good fast followers, if they see a new innovation or product feature from Lazada, they’re very quick to implement the same thing. And they’re doing it about three times better. So I think at this point in time because the market has matured somewhat, that people have formed their habits, their shopping habits. For Shopee, your average number of orders per month is somewhere like four or five times a month right. If you’re ordering that frequently, that brand stays in your head. So next time you do want to order something, your first go to Shopee and you probably already have the app downloaded on your phone and your phone is probably a little smartphone, doesn’t have that much space, so you don’t want to download too many apps. So these apps become almost like real estate on your mobile phone.
And if you the average number of times a person visiting the stores multiple times a day, right, and so it’s similar to going inside of a mall call it five times a day, you may not buy something the first four times, but the fifth time you walk past something and it seems attractive. So you make that purchase. It’s the same thing that Shopee is trying to invoke right now, get people using the app, get people spending as much time as possible on the app, and eventually, they’re going to find something that they like. So they just do a much better job of that than Lazada. And they in Indonesia, they’re the number one player.
Lazada, I believe it’s like number four last time I saw. In other countries, they’re a little bit more sticky and seem to be growing quicker. So, I think by this point, two years ago, the market controversy was: “How is Shopee going to be able to compete against the capital cannon of Alibaba and Softbank”? I think that question’s been kind of proven out already, which is why you see where shares are today. But I think it’s only just the beginning. Shopee is just starting to prove that they are the winner in the market. And typically, you see e-commerce as a winner take the most type of market.
And where you see the profitability come through is when the marketplace is two or three times larger than the next largest marketplace. So you can look at Shopee in Taiwan, for instance right. They have the dominant portion of market share, like 70, 80 percent rate, and that’s where they’re most profitable. So, if you watch how market share trends versus relative to other players, that is a good proxy for their eventual profitability as well.
What does Sea run?
[00:20:30] 
[00:20:52] 
And Shopee as an e-commerce marketplace and how it differs from something like Amazon or like I was saying, Lazada, is that they started more on the concept of the social networks. A lot of sellers at the time were selling on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, what have you. And so they created a system that was very easy to take the seller shops off of Instagram and important and onto the Shopee platform. On Instagram, basically people with a lot of items, there you would send a direct message. Them and negotiate the pricing, payment, where to send the payment, where to send the item. And it was a very clunky experience. And they noticed that a lot of people were doing that through the Pop Cap. And so they launched Shopee, which is a more formalized, lower friction type of marketplace, predominantly C2C, so consumers to consumers where they started off. And so that business has grown from 2015 to today, we think they’re going to do about over 30 billion in GMV on an overall level.
They’re still not profitable, but you have to look at it on a country basis. Like I said, Taiwan is already profitable, Indonesia is close to break even, and then the other countries. We’re sure that they’re going to break even within the next two years or so now. So that’s their second business. And that’s kind of what’s driven the stock over the last year or so.
And then their third business is called Sea Money. It’s their E-wallet platform in addition to the offer seller loans. And so this is synergistic with the Shopee business because a big issue in the region is for Mom and Pops sellers: They store their extra inventory in their second bedroom. And so they have a bunch of these holiday sales. You have like ten, ten, eleven, eleven, nine, nine, twelve, and twelve. And you get these huge spikes in these holiday sales. As a seller, the biggest problem is that you often run out of inventory during peak sales and so the sellers need working capital in order to kind of meet those spikes in demand. And It will help with retention. And then also as an E-wallet platform, they’re starting to go offline as well. And so we can see kind of what Alipay has done in China to get a good idea of what the road map looks like Shopee. Yeah, those are the three core businesses of Sea at the moment.
How early is e-commerce there?
[00:24:22] 
[00:24:25] 
[00:24:56] 
[00:25:01] 
[00:25:04] 
[00:25:06] 
But if you’re in a city of 20 million people in China, going to the store is a really big pain. And so you tend to use these e-commerce services a little bit more. It’s why you see like food delivery taking off in China as well. So I would think that Southeast Asia because it is more dense than places like the US, will be able to exceed where the US kind of peters out in terms of mature penetration in the market. But it’s too early to tell, these businesses change over time. Consumer habits change over time. There may be, I don’t know, instant teleportation of goods that you order and maybe someone will come out with that in 20 years or something. So it’s really hard to gauge where the top of that s curve is. So I would just say, look, maybe three to five years ahead, you can probably get more confidence there. But as to where these firms hit that top of that S curve, you should keep a close eye on it. But it’s anyone’s guess.
How did Hayden Capital find value in the 2020 crisis?
TL;DR: Hedges added a couple of percent, and Shopee reported about 140% GMV growth in April 2020. He uses an S curve to judge valuations.
How did the portfolio hold up?
[00:26:47] 
[00:27:21] 
[00:27:33] 
[00:27:42] 
And then people quickly realized that these are beneficiaries of this trend and that a lot of these customers who may not have used these platforms before. If you have a great mousetrap, they’re going to stick inside of that mousetrap and they’re going to refer more of their friends. Right, even after corona virus ends. And so I think that’s why you’ve seen such a rapid rebound in this space. And I think that one thing that’s interesting is that a lot of people, and I talked about this in my last letter as well, that a lot of people are trying to look at the traditional brick and mortar space and gauge when is the US going to open up? When are certain countries going to open back up? When is traffic going to normalize?
I think that’s a really hard game to play, at least from my standpoint. I think a lot of people won’t make a lot of money doing that. But in my view, I think that I just don’t have an edge there. And so I think the best opportunity is actually to think about who is a beneficiary during periods like this. If you think about a lot of these tech companies, these Internet companies, you’ve seen the news about work from home and whatnot. These are a very resilient type of businesses. Right? If you can have your entire workforce working from home and not be in a physical office, not have to have a physical presence, that’s a resilient type of business.
So, I think the opportunity is even in the emerging market space where things like Shopee have a three percent market share. There are other companies out there. We were looking to buy “Buy now, pay later” type of companies. These are a small portion of the market businesses that have a superior mousetrap. Once people learn about this business model that they will use it, that they think it’s a superior way to buy something. And so these types of businesses, because they’re so nascent and the biggest friction point is educating consumers. They benefit the most during something like this where consumers are naturally looking for a way to buy things online. So I think a lot of investors kind of focus their time there, in my opinion.
Are his holdings still cheap?
[00:31:18] 
[00:31:36] 
Which companies look overvalued?
[00:32:26] 
[00:32:36] 
And so the question is, which companies do have a superior mousetrap as a business model and as a product? Which serve their customers the best as opposed to their customers just being forced to use the product during this period of time, and they’re going to leave as soon as they have a chance. Those are probably the most overvalued segments of the market right now because I think we’re in a period of high valuations, at least within the last month or two. Everything is just kind of trading together everyone thinks that these Internet companies will all benefit, and that’s not true. Some of these will go back to kind of the levels that they were at in terms of consumer demand and whatnot.
[00:34:01] 
[00:34:10] 
What was Shopee valued at?
[00:34:42] 
[00:35:17] 
And so those are the situations where you have Shopee that grew over one hundred percent for a couple of years and their earnings power was kind of growing in line with that. And on top of that, as they kind of prove to the market that this business is stable, this business is capable of generating cash flow and that they will be the winner in the market, you get a valuation rerating, right? You started at basically a multiple of zero. And now I’m sure the market is valuing at close to 10x or whatever. And so I think with these earlier stage companies where you are, it’s a new business model. Maybe it only started existing a couple of years ago.
You need to have confidence that even if they aren’t profitable yet, they do have a pathway to profitability. And that, again, it all derives from what is their relative market share versus competitors and what is the customer value proposition? Right. The problem is that a lot of public investors aren’t comfortable making those types of judgment calls. A lot of public investors may not do the necessary channel checks that understand what’s going on behind the scenes and what makes one marketplace stick versus another?
What makes the average customer of one marketplace use the product for an hour a day, and the other one maybe five minutes a day? And they may be valid, similarly. So I think for these companies, you need to be able to have those kinds of data points to understand what are the early signs of a marketplace that’s going to grow quicker than its competitors and then be willing to take that bet. I think that for certain names, they do get overvalued, so you want to think like if your earnings are catering at 50 percent, but it’s pricing in, say, the next four years of growth already. And so actually, let me see if I can draw something for you real quick.
[00:38:17] 
[00:38:39] 

And so you need to evaluate what is the slope of this curve. If this slope calls, it falls below. Know, we use a rough estimate of like 10 percent over the next three years, even though it might be a great company. I think it would be in times like that where you should consider starting to trim the position. But everything that we hold today, I think we’ll be able to meet that bar pretty, pretty easily.
What does Fred Liu think about JD.com and the internet in China?
TL;DR: JD customers may only order two or three times a year. China is getting very competitive, he says (2020).
What did JD’s order frequency lead to?
[00:39:46] 
[00:40:14] 

[00:40:20] 
[00:40:24] 
So that segment of the market is an issue as well. And the real problem is just the low order frequency of that platform. And so we found better opportunities in cases like Shopee where, as I said, customers order multiple times a month. The basket size is very sticky. It’s a fun product to use. JD is more of like an Amazon-type model where it’s about efficiency. You saw them benefit during this coronaviruses period because they have their internal logistic systems. They’re able to get your items to you basically on the same day. The problem is that your average customer may only use the platform two or three times a year. And so you constantly have to reacquire that customer as well. And so I think that just added a lot of friction. I’m sure JD will continue to do just fine. We just saw better opportunities.
How competitive is China’s internet market?
[00:41:56] 
[00:42:10] 
And then other products may be low frequency, but high margin type of lines such as hotel bookings or whatnot. And that’s what really kind of provides profitability to the business. But in general, I’ll say that China is just becoming much more competitive nowadays. I think a lot of Chinese companies are executing Western internet companies out. You’re seeing a lot of one of our themes is the cross-pollination of these business models. Right, because you have a lot of Silicon Valley-type of companies that are keeping a close eye on what the Chinese companies are doing. Like if you launch a new feature, like, let’s say live streaming right in, it increases your average retention of your users.
Like Amazon, I’m going to take a close look at that and see if it’s applicable to the US consumer as well, because you kind of has a roadmap already, right. That’s already been trialed in China. And you may have slight differences on the margins, but consumers are generally the same globally. So, yeah, I think that a lot of these companies are becoming more mature, more sophisticated, and it’s becoming a little bit tougher to find good values there.
How does Fred Liu look at Carvana and CarMax?
TL;DR: Online used car sales were at about 1% to 2% penetration. Hayden’s model had Carvana at about 15 billion dollars in sales within about four years (2020).
What about partner inventory?
[00:44:19] 
[00:44:39] 
Which playbook does Carvana follow?
[00:46:21] 
[00:46:51] 
So, yeah, my opinions haven’t changed at all. And you see during periods like the last couple of months, they raised money, even though they honestly didn’t need the money. They’re using it to get more aggressive during this period to take share at an above-trend level than they were going to do before. And so I think when your competitors are hurting. Yeah. And you aren’t as much, that’s when you should be getting aggressive. And they have access to capital that your local brick-and-mortar guy isn’t going to have. And so why not use that to your advantage? So I still think highly of them.
[00:48:14] 
[00:48:19] 
Do more online players help?
[00:48:56] 
[00:49:04] 
And especially in a case like a used car. You’re going to spend at least 10 hours evaluating what model you want, what dealer you want to buy it from. And during those 10 hours, if you came because of a CarMax commercial, you’re probably going to make your way towards Carvana because you’re going to price shop. And then if Carvana offers a better experience, if they offer a cheaper price, you’ll probably use that, even though it was CarMax that paid for that marketing.
You see this across other industries as well. For instance, Shopee Pay or Sea Money. In the case of Sea, they let competitors burn billions of dollars on this E-wallet initiative in Indonesia to educate the market. And then nowadays, as of a couple of months ago, they started getting aggressive because the market is now educated and so they can come in with the biggest use case, which is e-commerce. And automatically they reported 40 percent of their orders in Indonesia were the through their e-wallet this past quarter. I think when markets when the total industry market share as a percent of the addressable market is at single digits; you don’t need to worry about competition as much.
You just need to focus on executing yourself. It’s when you start getting to that high single-digit, 9- 10 percent penetration, that’s when you start putting heads against your competitors and that’s when you start the pay stops growing as rapidly. Right. Because now you need to take a piece from someone else in order to continue growing. That’s when you start seeing the problems around competition. But at a very, very early stage, I think the more marketing dollars that go into, the more it benefits everyone.
Where is Carvana on the S curve?
[00:51:44] 
[00:51:54] 
[00:52:03] 
[00:52:08] 
What is next for Fred Liu and Hayden Capital?
TL;DR: He re-evaluates every two to three years, wants analysts who hunt for ideas and says investors should meet people again, like 50 or 60 years ago (2020).
How does he manage concentration?
[00:52:50] 
[00:53:05] 
When would he sell?
[00:53:50] 
[00:53:58] 
How will the team grow?
[00:54:33] 
[00:54:47] 
So I hope to be able to add to that. I hope to be able to add people perhaps on the data side in order to kind of prove out these features, these PC’s are quantitative. But other than that, I think Hayden will always be concentrated. I think we will always be investing in these types of companies. Hopefully, my circle of competence will have expanded by that point to encompass adjacent industries as well. But at its core, I don’t think Hayden changed that much. You’ll still recognize the firm’s strategy, what we’re doing.
Good Investing Plus
Meet the experienced investors
Plus is our application-based community of 200+ investors. Around half run or support a fund, or allocate capital.
- Online: idea exchanges and events every two weeks
- In person: gatherings in the US and Europe
- Omaha: our 150+ member conference in AGM week
[00:56:04] 
[00:56:06] 
[00:56:09] 
[00:56:15] 
What is his advice?
[00:56:17] 
[00:56:42] 
[00:57:43] 
[00:57:51] 
[00:57:53] 
[00:58:26] 

- Got his first shares, from his father, at age 11 [00:02:23]
- Hayden held 300+ meetings or calls in the prior year [00:08:58]

